Paver path winds between gray resort buildings and cedar decks, bordered by dune grass and flowering plants.

Why Pajaro Dunes Sidesteps Santa Cruz County's New Vacation Rental Caps

Picture two coastal properties that hit the market the same week this fall. Both sit within a mile of the water. Both are priced in the same range. Both come with the obvious pitch: buy it, furnish it, rent it out when you're not using it.

Santa Cruz County spent most of 2025 rewriting how it regulates short-term rentals, and the rewrite is now fully in effect. The county's Board of Supervisors gave final approval to the overhaul on August 19, 2025, and the California Coastal Commission certified the coastal-zone provisions on April 16, 2026, which means the rules now apply everywhere in the unincorporated county, including the stretch of coastline that runs through Aptos and La Selva Beach. Everywhere, that is, except Pajaro Dunes.

A Rewrite Built Around Scarcity

The county didn't tighten these rules quietly. A staff report compiled in the fall of 2024 found that 665 of the county's 841 vacation rentals were non-hosted, meaning whole homes with no owner on site, and supervisors treated that number as evidence that short-term rentals were competing directly with local buyers for the same housing stock.

Supervisor Manu Koenig, who led the rewrite alongside Supervisor Justin Cummings, put the frustration plainly at a board meeting in August 2025, as reported by Santa Cruz Local:

"Nothing's more frustrating than bidding on a house and then losing the bid"

The finished ordinance backs that sentiment with hard numbers. Lookout reported that outside the county's three designated coastal zones, non-hosted rentals are now capped at 270 permits countywide and hosted rentals at 250.

The Zone That Includes La Selva Beach

Inside the three designated zones, the caps get more specific, and one of those zones is the Seacliff/Aptos/La Selva Beach Designated Area, which the county's own boundary description places along Monterey Bay from the Capitola city line through the community of La Selva Beach.

Lookout reported that the zone is now capped at 241 non-hosted vacation rental permits and up to 45 hosted permits, for a ceiling of 286 total. As of April 2024, the last count published before the rewrite, that zone already had 83 applications sitting on a waitlist, compared with just 12 in the Live Oak zone farther up the coast. Live Oak's own cap sits at 262 non-hosted permits with 18 hosted, and the Davenport/Swanton zone, the smallest of the three, tops out at 3 non-hosted and 4 hosted.

None of that touches Pajaro Dunes.

The Resort's Carve-Out from the County's System

The exemption isn't a loophole someone found. It's written directly into Santa Cruz County code. The sections governing both hosted rentals and vacation rentals each carry the same line: they do not apply to Pajaro Dunes, where rentals are instead governed by an existing development permit.

That phrasing matters because of when it shows up. The county's short-term rental code traces its amendments back through ordinances dated 2011, 2015, 2016, 2018, and 2020, each one tightening the rules for the rest of unincorporated Santa Cruz County. Every one of those amendments carried the same carve-out for Pajaro Dunes. The resort community was established in 1973, decades before the county built out a permit-and-waitlist system for short-term rentals, and it has operated its own on-site rental management infrastructure, with dozens of staff handling reservations, housekeeping, and maintenance, since well before that system existed. Pajaro Dunes remains outside the newer rules under the code's carve-out.

Here's what that looks like side by side for a buyer comparing the two:

Pajaro Dunes La Selva Beach / SALSDA zone
Governing authority Existing resort development permit Santa Cruz County short-term rental ordinance
Rental cap None imposed by the county 241 non-hosted + 45 hosted (286 total)
Waitlist (last published count, April 2024) Not applicable 83 pending applications
County permit path County process does not apply County permit process applies

What This Actually Means for a Buyer

None of this means a Pajaro Dunes purchase comes with zero rules. What the exemption removes is the county layer entirely. There's no application sitting behind 83 others.

A property in the SALSDA zone doesn't carry that certainty. If it doesn't, a buyer is stepping into a capped pool with a waitlist more than six times the size of Live Oak's as of the last public count.

Before writing an offer on a coastal property anywhere between Pajaro Dunes and the SALSDA boundary near La Selva Beach, it's worth confirming a few things directly rather than assuming from the listing:

  • Whether the property currently holds an active, valid short-term rental permit, and whether that permit transfers with the sale or has to be reapplied for
  • Which side of the SALSDA boundary the parcel actually sits on, since the zone line runs along Bonita Drive, San Andreas Road, and the Urban Services Line rather than following an intuitive street grid
  • Whether the listing's advertised rental income reflects a licensed, permitted operation

Two Questions Worth Asking First

Does being inside the SALSDA zone mean a property can never get a rental permit? Not necessarily. The caps limit how many new non-hosted and hosted permits the zone can issue going forward, which is exactly why the waitlist exists.

The county's rewrite was built to slow down a specific kind of growth, whole homes converting to full-time vacation rentals in neighborhoods where people also live year-round. Pajaro Dunes was built as a resort from the start. Its exclusion from the county's rules is set out in the code's carve-out. For a buyer weighing rental income as part of the purchase, that difference is no longer a footnote. It's the first thing worth checking, before the price per square foot.

If you're comparing coastal properties for their rental potential and want a clear read on which permit path applies before you make an offer, Melanie & Natalia can walk through the specifics with you. Schedule a Consultation to talk through what a given property, and its zone, actually allows.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Work With Us

With a deep understanding of Capitola’s market and a personalized approach, Melanie and Natalia are your trusted partners in turning real estate goals into reality.

Follow Me on Instagram